Pros and Cons of Managed Care

According to Statista, around 54% of Americans have healthcare through private insurance their employers provide. Even though the performance and availability of healthcare in the United States are not as good as in most other high-income countries, this is still considered the norm. Managed care is a system that attempts to control the cost and quality of care by both providing coverage and managing healthcare services. It has been a growing trend in the U.S. in recent decades, with many employers now offering it as an option for their employees. This article discusses the pros and cons of managed care and provides some insight into how it can help or hinder individuals seeking healthcare services.

What is Managed Care?

Managed care is a health insurance and delivery system in the United States that seeks to limit costs by managing the use and cost of healthcare services. It's an umbrella term encompassing several healthcare plans, including Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) and Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs).

Under managed care, providers contract with insurance companies or employers to provide health services at pre-negotiated rates. In exchange for lower premiums, members must usually choose from a network of approved providers, receive referrals for specialized care and follow certain rules established by the plan.

Apart from providing financial protection against unexpected medical expenses, managed care also emphasizes preventive care and early diagnosis so patients can manage chronic conditions before they become expensive. Managed care also promotes cost-effectiveness in healthcare delivery by encouraging treatment from lower-cost providers, such as primary care physicians rather than specialists.

Managed care has become increasingly popular in the US due to rising healthcare costs. It's estimated that over 70% of Americans are enrolled in a managed care plan. While managed care can help manage medical costs and ensure access to quality healthcare, it can also be restrictive and leave patients with limited choices regarding doctors and treatments covered. Critics have raised concerns about managed care leading to higher out-of-pocket expenses for consumers and deteriorating patient satisfaction levels.

What are the Pros of Managed Care?

Although managed care is a popular healthcare system, it may not be the ideal choice for everyone. Therefore, exploring other healthcare alternatives that could be more advantageous based on individual circumstances is important. Here are some of the apparent advantages of managed care.

1. Lower Costs

A managed care system aims to provide quality healthcare at reduced costs by establishing a network of providers offering necessary care and referrals. Staying within the network for medical attention usually results in discounted rates for procedures and services.

2. Immediate Health Solutions for Families

In Canada's healthcare system, certain geographic areas may require you to wait over 40 weeks to see a specialist for an injury. Even non-life-threatening ailments may have even longer waiting periods. Managed care can be advantageous as it allows families to have immediate access to medical professionals. Though these services may come at a high cost, you can visit a doctor anywhere and be confident that your health needs will be expedited.

3. Preventative Care

Managed care systems are often tailored to improve preventative measures. This is done by regularly scheduling checkups and providing preventive screenings and wellness programs, including nutrition counseling, stress management classes, smoking cessation programs, etc. As a result, individuals can identify and address health issues before they become serious or costly.

4. It Brings Families Together

Managed care allows families to be involved in their healthcare system. For instance, parents can ensure their children receive the necessary preventive care, while siblings and relatives can provide emotional support when needed. Furthermore, it allows family members to come together and discuss treatments or action plans should a medical emergency arise.

5. Guaranteed Care within Network

To ensure effective patient care, managed care networks require their providers to undergo accreditation. Even though there may be a push to hire less experienced providers to reduce costs, accreditation guarantees a certain minimum level of care. This gives patients peace of mind knowing they will receive adequate care.

What are the Cons of Managed Care?

Despite its advantages, managed care has some drawbacks that could prove costly if not carefully considered. Here are some of the potential disadvantages of using a managed care system:

1. Limited Choice in Providers & Services

With managed care plans, you will typically be limited to choosing from a specific list of approved providers within their network. If those within the network do not meet your healthcare needs, you will likely be required to pay for out-of-network care. Some managed care plans may also limit the services and treatments you can receive.

2. Inadequate Communication between Patients & Providers

Managed care companies often focus on cost-cutting measures such as reducing the face-to-face time between patients and their providers. This lack of communication can lead to misdiagnoses or inadequate treatment plans due to difficulty accurately interpreting patient concerns and symptoms.

3. Poor Quality Care

While some managed care networks strive to provide quality healthcare at a lower cost, evidence suggests that the overall standards of care have suffered in certain areas. This is because managed care focuses on cutting costs rather than providing quality and comprehensive care.

4. Unfair Treatment of Patients

In some cases, managed care companies have been accused of discriminating against certain groups of people by denying them access to certain services or treatments for no other reason than cost savings. This has caused patients to be treated unfairly and, in some cases, receive inadequate medical attention. Furthermore, if a patient is denied treatment, they may be unaware of the cause.

5. Potential Conflict of Interest

Managed care organizations focus on improving profits more than providing quality care. This can lead to potential conflicts between their financial interests and the best health interests of their patients. Some of these conflicts include patients being pushed towards less expensive treatments and providers who are not necessarily the best fit for their health needs.

Managed care can be beneficial when properly utilized. However, it also has its drawbacks that should be considered before committing to a plan. By evaluating all aspects of a managed care system – from provider selection to service availability – you can ensure that you receive quality healthcare at an affordable price.


Managed care is valuable for those seeking cost-effective medical care with access to various providers and services. With careful consideration and evaluation, individuals can ensure they receive the highest quality health care within the confines of their budget. As long as the advantages of managed care outweigh its potential drawbacks, this system can be a great alternative for individuals and families looking to get quality healthcare without breaking the bank.

Pros and Cons of Managed Care

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Managed Care?

The advantages of managed care include access to a wide range of providers and services, lower costs, and peace of mind knowing that you will receive adequate care. Potential drawbacks are limited choice in providers and services, inadequate communication between patients and providers, poor quality care, unfair treatment of patients, and potential conflicts of interest.

What Should I Consider Before Choosing a Managed Care Plan?

It is important to consider all aspects of the managed care plan before committing to it. Make sure that you have access to a wide range of providers and services that meet your needs. Also, consider the quality of provider networks, cost-containment measures in place, and potential drawbacks such as limited choice in treatments or inadequate communication between patients and providers.

What are the Alternatives to Managed Care?

Other alternatives to managed care include fee-for-service plans, high-deductible health plans, and medical savings accounts. Fee-for-service plans allow individuals to pay for each service they receive, such as doctor’s visits or lab tests. High-deductible health plans require patients to pay a certain amount of out-of-pocket expenses before insurance kicks in. On the other hand, medical savings accounts allow people to save money tax-free for medical costs. These options may be more suitable d

What's your reaction?

© 2024 All right reserved.
  • Facebook page
  • Twitter page
  • instagram page