Pros and Cons of an ESOP

Employee Stock Ownership Plans, or ESOPs plans, are common terms you may hear these days, whether in a small or a big company. Many renowned companies in the United States allow their employees to have company shares through ESOP plans. That’s one easy way to be an employee-owned company. You wouldn’t be surprised if you came to the fact that some of the leading organizations are 100% and to the least, 50% employee-owned.

What are the Pros of an ESOP?

There are doubtlessly many positive outcomes of choosing an ESOP. Some of the key benefits of an ESOP are:

1. Increased Productivity

By having a stake in the company, employees will likely be more motivated and committed to their job duties, leading to higher productivity overall. But How? Let’s dig into it deeper. ESOPs are great tools for helping to increase productivity in the workplace.

And by making employees feel like part owners of the business, ESOPs give them a stake in the success or failure of the company. This can help motivate them to work hard, resulting in greater productivity from each employee and the entire team.

It can create a sense of loyalty among workers that benefits their overall morale and job satisfaction. Also, offering stock options has resulted in higher employee retention rates, which helps reduce costs associated with hiring and training new employees.

2. Tax Benefits

There are numerous benefits of an ESOP for employees and employers. For employers, the key tax benefit of ESOPs is the ability to deduct contributions made into these plans from their taxable income. This deduction can be up to 25% of total wages paid during the current year.

Since ESOP contributions are not subject to federal or state payroll taxes, employers can realize additional savings in terms of reduced payroll taxes. Depending on the type of plan selected by the employer and certain qualifications met, employers may be able to take an additional deduction for contributions made more than the 25% limitation.

For employees, ESOP plans also offer favorable tax treatment. Employees are not taxed on any income generated from their shares until they sell or dispose of them. At that time, any realized gains will be taxed at long-term capital gains rates instead of ordinary income. This difference can have a significant impact on the amount of taxes due. Moreover, most plans allow employees to defer taxation until retirement or other special events occur when the shares are disposed of.

3. Morale Boosters

Employee Stock Option Plans are designed to incentivize, retain and reward employees by giving them a financial stake in their employer's success. By giving employees an ownership interest in the company, ESOPs can significantly boost morale and employee loyalty and engagement.

The structure of these plans often provides employees with a feeling of empowerment, appreciation, and security that comes from being part owners of the business they work for. This encourages retention as it incentivizes employees to stay at the firm to maximize their return on investment.

4. Retention of Talent

ESOP plans provide employees with financial incentives to stay with the company by awarding them a stake in its future success. This motivates employees to work harder and invest more in their employer's performance, as they now have skin in the game.

And when employees receive stock options or ownership shares as part of their compensation package, it helps create a sense of loyalty amongst them and increases retention rates.

It's important during transition or when resources are scarce to help ensure that highly valued personnel remain with the organization. ESOPs can help promote talent retention and foster a healthy work culture by providing a long-term incentive to stay with the company.

What are the Cons of an ESOP?

Just like with most things, there can be some downsides to establishing an Employee Stock Option Plan. Here is a look at the main disadvantages of an ESOP.

1. Costly

Setting up and managing an ESOP can be costly as it requires legal fees and compliance costs that you need to consider, especially when you run a small company or a start-up. It is also important to ensure that all employees understand the rules surrounding how much stock they can acquire and when this will happen.

2. Risk of Dilution

Companies issue shares to employees with an ESOP as part of their compensation package. This results in a larger number of shareholders which can lead to a decrease in the value of existing shares due to the company's assets being divided more widely.

This could result in negative consequences for existing shareholders, including a decline in stock price or reduced dividend payments. If enough new shares are issued, it could cause the company to become over-capitalized, resulting in cash flow problems or even bankruptcy. That's why employers must take extra care when setting up ESOPs and be aware of the potential risks associated with dilution.

3. Risk to Employees

A company's stock is subject to market fluctuations, and ESOP Plans can potentially expose employees to a range of financial risks. These include:

  1. The value of an ESOP is typically tied to the value of the company's stock on the open market. If the stock price changes dramatically, it could result in a significant loss for employees who have invested in these plans.
  2. Some employers might manipulate their stocks' prices to increase their profits at their employees' expense. Since most ESOPs do not include any type of protection against bankruptcy, a company's financial collapse could also cause employees to suffer major losses from their investments.
  3. The complexity of these plans often makes it difficult for employees to understand exactly how much money they are investing and what kind of return they can expect.

4. Tax Implication

Tax implication is one of the hidden cons of an ESOP as employees who receive shares or stock options as part of an ESOP plan are usually subject to tax liability. This can range from capital gains taxes when the stock is sold, to income taxes on the value of the stock when it is issued. Furthermore, employers must also take into consideration that their contribution to the plan and any subsequent dividends paid out will be taxed as compensation for employees.


It is clear that while ESOPs offer a variety of benefits, some potential drawbacks you need to keep in mind. Companies should carefully weigh all of these factors before setting up an ESOP to protect their employees and the company’s bottom line.

Pros and Cons of an ESOP

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an ESOP?

An Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) is a type of employee benefit plan that allows employees to acquire stock in the company that they work for.

Are there any tax benefits associated with ESOPs?

Yes, both employers and employees can enjoy tax benefits from ESOPs on both state and federal levels.

What are some potential risks associated with setting up an ESOP?

The main risks associated with ESOPs include costliness and dilution of shares due to other types of equity or debt financing as well as market volatility which may lead to the decreased value of the stocks held by employees.

What are the benefits of setting up an ESOP?

The main benefits of setting up an ESOP include increased productivity, tax benefits, and morale boosters, and retaining top talent due to their stake in the company.

What's your reaction?

© 2024 All right reserved.
  • Facebook page
  • Twitter page
  • instagram page