Pros and Cons of Mandatory Military Service

There has been a lot of debate about mandatory military service in countries worldwide, with proponents arguing that it could create a stronger sense of patriotism and a more united society. In contrast, opponents say it could infringe on individual liberties and cause resentment towards the government. So, what are the pros and cons of mandatory military service? Let's explore both sides of the argument and provide all the necessary information.

What are the Pros of Mandatory Military Service?

Countries like China and the United States have invested mainly in military services for a good reason. The US military has the most enormous military force, and most of the investment is spent on jobs. Apart from that, here are some recognized pros of Mandatory Military Service.

1. "Manners Maketh a Man."

Discipline and mannerism are apparent advantages of mandatory military service in that it help to promote good manners. This is especially true in countries where the culture and customs are not as strict as others. By participating in compulsory military service, people can become more aware of their surroundings and how to act accordingly. They also get an opportunity to learn about discipline, respect, and proper etiquette.

2. Increased National Security

Mandatory military service also increases national security. Since more people are available to defend the nation in case of a conflict or an attack, it also ensures a steady stream of personnel for training exercises, which can help keep the defense infrastructure prepared in times of need.

3. Skill Development is one of the Common Pros of Mandatory Military Service

The military can provide training and experience in specific skills or trades, including engineering, healthcare, telecommunications, and cooking. If you complete your compulsory service, you can acquire valuable skills that you can use for the rest of your life. For example, you can start a training academy, be an electrician, or join schools as a Physical Education teacher.

4. Stronger Military Force

A mandatory military training system can lead to a stronger military force, which is necessary for maintaining national security and protecting citizens. Having a larger pool of trained individuals to draw from during war can make all the difference.

5. Improvement of Gender Equality

Mandatory military service can help improve gender equality by providing equal opportunities to both men and women. This is especially important in countries where traditional gender roles still exist, as it allows more people to contribute to the defense forces regardless of their sex or gender identity.

What are the Cons of Mandatory Military Service?

Training and deploying military professionals deliver many benefits to countries. However, there are many Cons of Mandatory Military Service, and most affect professionals’ well-being.

1. Potential for Human Rights Abuses

One of the main disadvantages of mandatory military service is that it may lead to human rights abuses, especially in countries with oppressive regimes. In such instances, people can be forced into military service without proper training or equipment and face dangerous conditions with no way out.

2. Economic Burden

The costs associated with maintaining a mandatory military service system can significantly burden the economy. This is especially true in countries already facing economic hardship, as resources may have to be diverted from other sectors (such as healthcare and education) to fund the military.

3. Loss of Civil Liberties is among the common cons of Mandatory Military Service

In some cases, mandatory military service can lead to a loss of civil liberties. For example, people may be forced to surrender certain rights or be subject to compulsory military service even if they do not wish to participate. This can create an atmosphere of enforced patriotism that some people feel uncomfortable with.

4. Mental Health Issues

People required to serve in the military can suffer from various psychological issues due to the stress and trauma of war. This can include depression, PTSD, anxiety, and more. It is essential to ensure that those who have served in the military are given adequate support and resources to help them cope with these issues.

5. Unfair Treatments

Mandatory military service can also result in unfair treatment and discrimination against certain groups. For example, people unable or unwilling to serve due to physical or mental health issues may be unfairly denied the same rights as those who did.

6. Resentment Towards Government

Many individuals who oppose mandatory service argue that it could lead to resentment toward the government. The belief that the government is controlling their lives could make people feel powerless and lead to distrust of the government.

Conclusion on Pros and Cons of Mandatory Military Service

The debate to this day with no clear consensus on the Pros and Cons of Mandatory Military Service. While it can provide a valuable source of training and experience for individuals, it also comes with the potential for human rights abuses and a loss of civil liberties. It is essential to consider all aspects of this issue before deciding whether mandatory military service should be implemented in a particular country. Ultimately, each nation must decide what is best for its citizens and security needs.

Regardless of which side of the argument you are on, it is essential to remember that any decision must be based on what is best for the nation and its citizens. It is also necessary to ensure that any mandatory military service system provides adequate training, support, and resources to those required to serve to protect their rights and well-being.

Pros and Cons of Mandatory Military Service

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the disadvantages of compulsory military service?

The military relies on funding provided by individuals working regular 9-5 jobs on the mainland. Implementing mandatory conscription would effectively deprive an individual of 2-3 years of their life, during which they would be unable to contribute to the country's economy.

Is compulsory military service good or bad?

Compulsory military service infringes upon the fundamental right of individuals to exercise their free will, disregarding their stance on participation in military training. This practice fails to acknowledge an individual's autonomy and choice, impeding the self-determination principle.

Why should military training not be compulsory for all?

Engaging in rigorous training may be beyond their physical abilities for some individuals. While they may appear ordinary, they could be dealing with mental illnesses. Military training can prove overwhelming for them with its demanding physical and emotional challenges. In such instances, mandatory training can significantly threaten their well-being and even their lives.

What are the adverse effects of military service?

Serving in combat and being separated from loved ones can induce significant stress, placing service members and veterans more vulnerable to mental health issues. These encompass anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, and substance misuse. Additionally, the risk of suicide must also be acknowledged and addressed.

What's your reaction?

© 2024 All right reserved.
  • Facebook page
  • Twitter page
  • instagram page